Below we have the ultimate unbiased comparison of the Puffy and the Puffy Lux Mattress. See which bed is best for you and your partner.
Puffy is one of the most popular beds-in-a-box mattress brands on the market today, and one of our favorites. In this comparison, we review the Original Puffy mattress and the Puffy Lux. We highlight the construction, feel, firmness, and the price of each mattress, as well as the pros and cons of sleeping on each. Then we make our official recommendations to help you decide if the Puffy, or Puffy Lux is right for you and your partner.
We’ll start this mattress comparison by saying that the original Puffy mattress and the newer Puffy Lux mattress are two phenomenal beds. Obviously, since both are manufactured by Puffy there are many similarities between the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattress. Both are made from the same material – memory foam, which means both offer a similar feel and adapt well to most sleep types.
There are certainly pros and cons to each mattress, but we can guarantee that the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses are well made, extremely comfortable, and we’ll priced. Regardless of the one you choose, you will wake feeling rested, healthy and ready to take on the day. Keep reading to learn more about Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses and see how they compare to each other.
First Things First:
It is worth noting that in early 2019 both of the Puffy mattresses received an upgrade in materials. With the addition of a layer of Climate Comfort Foam in the center of both beds. This allowed for not only a more ideal firmness level in both, but also is better for sleeping more temperature neutral and drier too. Creating two mattresses that will work for anyone looking for the best memory foam mattress on the market.
This upgrade changed the feel and performance of each mattress and broadened their appeal – now they are both considered to be the best memory foam mattress on the market today. Our Puffy vs Puffy Lux review take an honest, unbiased and thoughtfully objective look at both memory foam mattresses. We hope that our first hand experience of sleeping on each of these mattresses will help you decide which may be best for you!
When comparing the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses there is no way to make the wrong choice. Each is a phenomenal mattress but that won’t stop us from comparing the features of each. We made a side-by-side chart to make it easier to see the upgraded features included in the Puffy Lux. Keep reading for further details.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux Comparison Video:
If you’re looking for a more luxurious feel and more pressure relief, we recommend the Puffy Lux. However, if you prefer a slightly firmer feel, the original Puffy mattress is the bed for you.
Watch our in-depth video review of the Puffy vs Puffy Lux to see how each mattress provides a comfortable, supportive sleeping surface and offers its own unique appeal. See what we had to say, and don’t forget to take advantage of our coupons to save too!
Over the last few years Puffy has established itself as ne of the most trusted mattress brands in the industry. The Puffy mattress quickly gained popularity when introduced in 2017. Their popularity increased with the release of the Puffy Lux in 2018 – an upgraded 12″ all foam mattress that provided shoppers with an enhanced version of the original.
In 2019 both beds have been perfected. But which one is better for you? Is the Puffy Lux better than the original? Is the original Puffy the better choice? We’ll help you decide in our ultimate Puffy comparison review; Puffy vs Puffy Lux.
Puffy Mattress Overview:
The original Puffy mattress is a 10″ memory foam mattress with three layers of foam. Their patented Cooling Cloud foam and recently added ClimateComfort foam makes up the top 4″ of the bed and provide substantial comfort and pressure relief. The base of the Puff mattress is made of 6″ of solid Firm Core Support foam.
This balanced mattress provides a medium firm feel that is well-suited for all sleeping positions. An additional middle layer provides the mattress with even more support, which is appealing to side sleepers, back sleepers and even stomach sleepers.
The Puffy mattress is contouring, which means it envelops your body no matter your size, shape or weight. Our favorite part about this bed is how it’s focused on adapting to your body, and maintaining a cool and dry sleep surface.
This mattress is more reasonable than the Puffy Lux. It’s priced at $1,150 for a queen size – before adding our exclusive discount of $300, which makes it ONLY $850. You can learn more in our full, in-depth Puffy Mattress Reviews.
Puffy Lux Mattress Overview:
The upgraded Puffy Lux mattress is very similar to the original but comes with an additional 2″ layer of gel-infused foam. The additional 2″ gel-infused foam push the bed’s total thickness to 12”, which not only give the mattress a thicker profile, but gives it a better feel as well.
In our opinion, the added gel-infused foam layer makes the Puffy Lux bed mattress a premium bed, with a slightly softer feel and more than enough support. It’s also amenable to all sleeping positions, especially side sleeping.
One of our favorite features of the Puffy Lux is the Cooling Cloud comfort foam and the addition of the ClimateControl foam which ensures a nice temperature neutral sleep surface. The Puffy Lux mattress comes with a slightly higher price tag of $1,795 for a queen size – but that doesn’t include our exclusive $300 discount, which brings the price down to ONLY $1,495. You can learn more in our full, in-depth Puffy Lux Mattress Review.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Comfort Materials:
The materials of the Puffy and Puffy Lux provide a true memory foam feel. The original Puffy is a 10″ mattress comprised of three layers, while the Puffy Lux is a 12″ mattress of four layers. Both utilize many of the same comfort layers which combine to provide pressure relieving comfort and support, and to keep you sleeping in cool and dry all night long.
Both the Puffy and Puffy Lix mattresses include a top layer of 2″ of original Cooling Cloud Memory Foam – ideal for maximum pressure relief and even weight distribution. It’s also meant to adapt to your body and contour around its curves perfectly. One of the greatest things about the memory foam used in the Puffy mattresses is that it’s designed to pull heat away from the body 8x better than average memory foam, which helps you sleep cool and comfortable.
2″ of ClimateComfort Foam aides in keeping the mattress cool. It’s a very consistent feeling foam that conforms to your body for a weightless sleeping experience. It’s an advanced material that is temperature and humidity-resistant, which provides the bed with just a hint of softness and deep comfort to cradle your body, and allow you to sleep in all sleeping positions.
The Puffy Lux features a third comfort layer of Body Adapting Dual Cloud Foam. This layer is between the top layer of Cooling Cloud Foam and the ClimateComfort foam. It not only adds 2″ to the overall thickness of the mattress but creates an almost zero gravity type feel. It creates a perfect contour around your body, eliminating pressure points and providing an almost weightless feeling. This enhances your sleep quality and helps you get even better rest to recharge and rejuvenate night after night.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Support Materials:
Both beds have a 6″ base of Firm Core Support Foam that provides a dense base layer. This sturdy core support creates ideal spinal support and optimal ergonomic alignment. It provides for a consistent feeling mattress that is solid and durable, with plenty of longevity and comfort for years and years.
This base layer is exceptional when compared to the average base foam used in all foam mattresses. The support foam of the Puffy mattresses uses Insta-Firm Technology, which allows the core to provide 4x more support than typical base foam. It’s also 99% more responsive.
This helps to not only enhance support but also provides benefits typically reserved for the top comfort layers. By focusing on the details in every layer of the Puffy and Puffy Lux has created two mattresses that are well designed, technologically driven, supportive bed that is durable enough to provide years of great sleep.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Covers:
When it comes to mattress covers you might not think there is too much about it. Most you don’t even see once bedding is on. And many people use protectors to help keep their mattress investments cleaner. However, having a mattress that has a more sleeper friendly cover, like the Puffy and Puffy Lux, can be beneficial.
Both the Puffy mattress and Puffy Lux mattress feature a thick, yet breathable cover. Two very distinct and important features of this cover are its ability to be removed and washed. And, the technology driven protection against stains. These two things not only keep your mattress much cleaner, but also ensure the longevity you would expect.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Comfort:
The Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses vary in overall firmness. The original Puffy mattress uses three layers of foam that provide a true medium-firm feel. The Puffy Lux has four layers and offers a slightly softer feel, which borders between medium and medium-firm.
The firmness of a mattress correlates with a rough number on the firmness scale, ranging from soft (0-1) all the way to firm (10). This gives us a better idea of how each mattress will feel to various sleepers.
The Puffy comes in around a 6 to 8 on the firmness scale. Which will be a luxury firm or medium-firm feel. It’s a little firm for a smaller frame and a little soft for larger individual.
The Puffy Lux mattress is plusher at medium to medium-firm feel. Which is around a 5 to 7 on the firmness scale.
This difference may not seem like much. But the added 2″ of Body Adapting Dual Cloud foam does make the Puffy Lux more appealing to a larger variety of sleepers. This added pressure relieving foam creates a layer of deep comfort that puts the Puffy Lux at a very happy medium that accommodates all sleeping styles very comfortably.
The original Puffy falls just a bit outside of the overlapping section of all three sleeping positions, which makes it ideal for stomach sleepers and back sleepers, and good for side sleepers who like a more supportive feel. But there may be a few people that like the added benefits of the additional 2″ of the Puffy Lux.
Have you made up your mind? Shop the Puffy and Puffy Lux at Puffy.com!
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Our Comfort Pick:
When it comes to our choice for comfort, the Puffy Lux edges out the original Puffy mattress. It has a more adaptable sleeping surface that is well-suited for all sleeping positions, which is great for couples.
Justin sleeps mostly on his back, while I sleep in all positions, especially side and stomach. The puffy Lux works great for both of us. We prefer mattresses that offer a medium to medium-firm feel, which puts the Puffy Lux into the sweet spot that works best for us.
We were pleasantly surprised with the true dense memory foam top layers but noticed the benefits of the third plush comfort layer the longer we slept on it. The support was still ideal but the contouring to your shoulders and hips was very precise and really pushed the pressure relief to another level. Though this is a true memory foam mattress, it’s very responsive – enough to never feel stuck and to make it easy to change positions.
The Puffy Lux is going to be very similar to a number of Tempurpedic mattresses out there, but might not cost as much. This gives it a desirable feel that is easy on your checkbook, as well as your spine. If you like the true memory foam feel, but want to keep your investment under a $1000, the original Puffy is a great option. It also does a great job of relieving pressure and sleeping cool.
Regardless of which Puffy mattress is right for you make sure you get the best pricing! Use the link below to save on both the Puffy & Puffy Lux mattresses.
Memory Foam and Comfort:
Both of these mattresses are memory foam and overall provide a dense memory foam feel. This means the top layer is slower to respond. It’s great for pressure relief and contouring to your body. However, with any memory foam there are a few things that are good to know up front, especially if you’ve never slept on a memory foam bed.
Regardless of the bed you decide to purchase, it’s going to take your body some time to adjust to it. However, making a drastic jump from an innerspring mattress to an all foam mattress will likely take your body several weeks to adjust to. This is normal, but something also something to keep in mind when determining whether or not to return the mattress.
Traditional memory foam is slower to respond and sometimes can take a second to catch up with your body. This means that changing positions or getting in and out of bed can feel like you’re stuck in the bed, especially with standard memory foams that lack any buoyancy or responsiveness.
The nice thing about both Puffy mattresses is their innovative memory foam. So, even though they both have the contouring benefits of memory foam, they also have just enough responsiveness so you don’t feel stuck. This gives the Puffy and Puffy Lux all the like you can benefits of memory foam with none of the consequences.
Memory Foam and Heat:
Memory foam also has a tendency to be affected by temperature. The mattress will become slightly denser if it is in a colder room, while being in a warmer room makes it softer. This can make a difference depending on the climate of where you live or the temperature you like to keep your room at.
A memory foam mattress will also warm to your body, which makes heat retention a common problem, especially if the base of the bed is foam too. This can make sleeping cool an issue. It also can make the mattress slightly softer when the bed warms to your body heat.
Puffy was aware of the common issues with memory foam made sure to alleviate them in the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses. They focused on heat dissipating technology that keeps the bed temperature neutral, and helps you sleep cool and dry.
So if you may think you are getting an old school heat retaining and slow responding memory foam, think again. With the Puffy and Puffy Lux you get the latest generation of memory foam that will have you thinking differently about every all foam mattress.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Motion Isolation:
If you are a light sleeper, you have a different sleep schedule than your partner. Or you sleep with someone who tosses and turns then this section is a must read. Motion transfer is problematic for many mattresses but not for the Puffy and Puffy Lux.
These all foam beds do a great job at reducing and absorbing any excess movement before it ever reaches your sleeping partner. The abundant layers of foam in each is not only dense, but phenomenal at reducing vibrations. This means any movements, whether soft or strong, will be isolated at the action – the person on the other side of the bed is less likely to feel their partner shifting or moving.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Sleeping Cool:
As previously mentioned, both of the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses use the same Cooling Cloud memory foam in their top layer. They also utilize the ClimateComfort memory in the second layers. This is very relevant to sleeping cool, or at least sleeping temperature neutral.
The memory foam in the Puffy bed and Puffy Lux bed is a technologically-driven foam that uses science to keep overheating at bay. The cooling cloud foam uses conduction and convection to not only pull heat away from the body. But also generate air flow. Which makes the memory foam less warm over the course of a night than standard memory foam.
ClimateComfort foam also keeps the bed dry because you’re body remains cooler, and is therefore less likely to sweat. The Puffy and Puffy Lux also use a breathable, soft cover that helps the mattress to easily dissipate any heat , and keeps the mattress feeling cool to the touch.
The biggest difference between these two mattresses may be the firmness of each. The slightly softer feel of the Puffy Lux may cause you to sink into the mattress more than the Puffy. Keep in mind that the more of your body that touches the bed, the more heat is retained by the foam. You’re less likely to sink into a firm mattress, therefore less likely to overheat.
Make sure to get your Puffy or Puffy Lux NOW at Puffy.com! And you’ll be sleeping cool and on a cloud in a few short days!
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Edge Support:
Edge support is be a telltale sign of the quality and longevity you can expect from a mattress. The edge of the mattress showcases the density of the foams used inside and the quality of its construction.
High edge support increases the durability of a mattress, which adds to its longevity. Edge support also helps to keep your body on the mattress. Because you wont roll off the side, you get to use more of your bed.
Both the Puffy mattress and Puffy Lux mattress use very dense foams. This benefits the edge of the mattress by creating a fully usable sleep surface that doesn’t change consistency. It also makes for an edge that can be minimally utilized for sitting too. We like to stress that a mattress shouldn’t be used as a chair. But there are instances when a solid edge is necessary when sitting. Both of these beds provide a rigid perimeter that not only are great for sleeping but also occasional sitting.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux Value:
The Puffy Lux is a bit more expensive than the original Puffy mattress. However, you are getting a more adaptable and ultimate pressure relieving feel, a thicker bed and a few other benefits to create an even more ideal sleeping surface. Making both of these beds a great value for what you are getting.
The Puffy bed and the Puffy Lux mattress both offer true, yet responsive memory foam that contours to your body to relieve pressure. The support is solid, but the feel varies slightly between either end of the medium-firm spectrum.
If you like the true feeling of memory foam with the integrations of the latest technology, then either of these options would be for you. Though, if you prefer a thinner profile and have a tighter budget, then the less expensive original would be for you. If you want an added layer to provide ultimate pressure relief and a premium feel than the more expensive Puffy Lux may be the way to go.
Make sure to shop at Puffy.com to get these two awesome cloud like memory foam mattresses and find the latest pricing below.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress Coupons:
The Puffy and Puffy Lux are comparable in price with several direct competitors, but vary greatly when compared to each other. Fortunately, you can use a generous Puffy coupon (applicable to each) to knock $300 off the total price.
To use the Puffy mattress coupon and get the best pricing be sure to follow the latest Puffy promo code just found below. The added Puffy mattress discount really helps improve the value of both of these beds.
Puffy Mattress Pricing:
*With $300 Puffy Discount
- Twin – $525
- Twin XL – $575
- Full – $695
- Queen – $850
- King – $1050
- California King – $1050
Puffy Lux Pricing:
*With $300 Puffy Lux Discount
- Twin – $1145
- Twin XL – $1195
- Full – $1295
- Queen – $1495
- King – $1695
- California King – $1695
As Seen On Ellen:
If you haven’t already seen Puffy Lux featured on the Ellen Show, now you can!
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Customer Service:
Puffy is known for great customer service and benefits. These include a 101 night trial period to test the mattresses and make sure they’re a good fit. If for some reason it doesn’t work out, Puffy has an easy return process. One thing to keep in mind with the Puffy or Puffy Lux, and any new mattress for that matter, is allowing your body time to adjust. It takes time for your body to adjust to any new mattress. So be sure you take advantage of the FULL 101 day sleep trial to get the best idea of how your body feels on the mattress
They also both come with free shipping. These mattresses are roll packed after they are made to order right here in the USA. They are then shipped via fed-ex and will arrive right at your door in a few days.
There’s also the lifetime warranty that comes with any Puffy mattress. As long as you own your mattress, you are covered. This warranty covers replacing your mattress with a new one. This is if there are any material defects or workmanship flaws in the first 10 years. After the first 10 years if there are any defects uncovered the mattress will either be repaired or replaced.
Start your 101 night sleep trial for the Puffy or Puffy Lux now! Shop at Puffy.com!
Puffy Mattress Complaints:
Prior to 2019, the biggest Puffy mattress complaint was that it felt too firm. This made it more difficult for side sleepers to find the ideal level of comfort. Though the Puffy Lux was a great option, anyone who couldn’t afford the upgrade may have felt let down.
Fortunately, the Puffy and Puffy Lux revamped their design to appeal to all sleep types. The Puffy bed now provides a medium to medium-firm feel. While the Puffy Lux got an additional layer of foam to increase its adaptability. Puffy’s revamp of the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses seems to have the desired effect. Especially since Puffy now experiences far fewer complaints in 2019 than they did last year.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux – Summary:
Both of these mattresses appeal to similar sleepers searching for a perfect memory foam mattress. Anyone who likes a true memory foam mattress, made with dense and durable feeling foams will approve of either option.
Both provide terrific motion and temperature neutrality, and provide solid and consistent foams for long-term durability. The comfort foam, thickness, and pricing will create the biggest decisions you’ll face when choosing which of the Puffy mattresses is best for you.
The original Puffy mattress is great for anyone on a tighter budget. Anyone who wants a true memory foam feel that doesn’t like the typical heat retaining feel of memory foam. As well as for anyone who sleeps on their side, back and even stomach that likes more of a medium to medium-firm feel.
While anyone who likes an enhanced premium pressure relieving feel and a thick mattress may like the feel of the upgraded Puffy Lux mattress. This bed also works great for all sleeping positions. And though it may cost a bit more, does have the benefits that coincide with the cost.
Even though the price may make you sway one way or the other it is a good idea to keep in mind your true needs. To compromise comfort for a few hundred extra dollars will more than likely not be worth it in the long run. So accommodating your body first is definitely recommended when choosing between the Puffy vs Puffy Lux mattresses.
Make sure to get your discounted Puffy or Puffy Lux NOW at Puffy.com! And you’ll be sleeping on a cloud in a few short days!
Puffy & Puffy Lux Video Reviews:
Watch our in-depth video reviews too! Below we have both the Puffy Lux video and the original Puffy video. Check them out to see how they performed for us!
Also, there is plenty more beyond the Puffy vs Puffy Lux. Make sure you check out all the other Puffy comparison reviews featured in our Mattress Comparisons. We feature the Puffy vs Purple as well as the Puffy Lux vs Purple. And the Puffy vs Casper, Puffy vs Leesa and Puffy vs Nectar. And even the Puffy Lux vs Loom and Leaf and Puffy Lux vs Nolah 12″ Signature.
Or to compare any of our reviewed mattresses utilize our unique and one of a kind Mattress Comparison Tool. It is great for getting a glance at several mattresses side by side. Our goal is to help you get the best nights sleep possible.
Learn more about each mattress featured in their full reviews too: Puffy Review & Puffy Lux Review. And always remember Our Sleep Guide is here to help you find your next perfect mattress. If you have any questions along the way feel free to contact us. Also, see what makes us different, as well as a trusted mattress review site in our Unbiased Mattress Reviews guide.