Please note, Our Sleep Guide is proudly supported by our readers. The product links you’ll find on Our Sleep Guide are referrals and if you purchase an item we do make a small compensation. Please see our disclosure page for full details.
If you are looking for an all foam mattress and have it narrowed down between a Puffy and Nolah, than keep reading! This comparison review is going to go through the details of each memory foam mattress to see which maybe a better fit for you. Continue on to see the pros, cons and similarities and differences in our Puff vs Nolah mattress review.
The Puffy mattress is a mattress type inspired by the idea of sleeping on a cloud. The top layer is a thick layer of body adapting and pressure relieving memory foam. The layers of this mattress have been meticulously designed over the course of several years giving you a top mattress sleeping experience
This allowed for plenty of time to provide the most ideal medium-firm comfort available so you can live and sleep in comfort. The Puffy mattress hasn’t been on the market long, but it’s popularity is growing with rapid momentum as an excellent bedding mattress. Puffy is not only a great brand but they also give back to the community. They make jumping on the bed a fun way to donate memory foam mattresses to children in need. Learn more HERE!
Nolah Mattress Overview:
The Nolah mattress is made by a company that was driven to find the best and most innovative & technology advanced foams to improve upon the memory foam mattress and provide similar benefits to hybrid mattresses with latex too. This focus allowed them to create a new foam that has the benefits of memory foam. However, it is even more pressure relieving and doesn’t hold the heat unlike other mattress types on the market. It also incorporates Avena foam which is similar in feel to latex but even more durable for a top mattress experience.
These layers have been carefully crafted to find the best medium comfort out there. The Nolah mattress is not only super comfortable but also does good too. Saving an animal through Defenders of Wildlife with every mattress purchased.
We are putting these mattresses head to head in our Puffy vs Nolah mattress comparison. Looking at the similarities and differences and giving our honest feedback. Read on to find out how we felt about each of these brands as well as see which one will be a better fit for you in this buying guide and mattress review.
Puffy vs Nolah: Delivery & Off Gassing:
The differences in the delivery, off gassing and overall unboxing process are about a horse a piece. Each of these natural mattresses are delivered for free a few days after order and typically through Fed-Ex or UPS. Both Nolah and Puffy are made in the USA, compressed, put into a compact box and arrive easily at your door. Neither one of these bed in a boxes will have much many noxious odors or fumes, a great benefit of natural mattresses like these where you can also get a sleep trial period to see which ones work best for your sleeping experience. Regardless though you do want to let either air out for a few hours after opening.
Another thing to note with both mattresses is that they will take a few hours to fully expand after being packaged. Definitely let them expand and breathe for about 3 to 4 hours, at a minimum, before sleeping. This not only ensures a nice feeling bed but one free of any lingering smells too.
Puffy vs Nolah: Comfort:
Looking at comfort from an objective standpoint the best way to start is the overall firmness of the mattress. Each bed can range form soft to firm and everything in between. We usually compare each feel on a scale form 1 to 10 with 1 being soft and 10 firm. As far as these two beds go we found that they did vary quite a bit for firmness.
Even though both of these mattresses are offered in a universal feel, that feel is quite different between the two. The Puffy will be around a 7 to 7.5 on a firmness scale. This being a bit firmer than the ideal sweet spot that works for almost every sleeper, making the Puffy a firm mattress. The Nolah on the other hand was right around a 5 to 5.5 with borders on the sweet spot at around a 6.
This makes both of these mattresses more ideal for certain sleepers. Puffy is definitely a bit too much of a firm mattress for the prominent side sleeper. However, back sleepers and stomach sleepers who like a dense memory foam feel will appreciate the firmness and feel of this bed. In short, we would not recommend this as a mattress for side sleepers, however, it will do quite well as a mattress for stomach sleepers and people who sleep on their backs.
Nolah is going to be much more appealing for side sleepers and back sleepers who like a little more give. It will provide good pressure relief for the shoulder and hip while on your side as well as for your lumbar and neck on your back. This mattress is great for anyone who want an all foam mattress that is contouring but still just responsive enough too.
The Puffy mattress is a 10″ thick mattress with 2 layers of foam. The top layer is going to be 3″ of cooling cloud memory foam. This layer of memory foam is supportive and adaptive to every point of your body. It really focuses on relieving pressure from head to toe. This allowed for a nice thick layer of conforming comfort that still allows for ample support and just the right amount of response. The base layer is 7″ of dense base foam that incorporate Insta-Firm technology that makes for a more responsive as well as more supportive base foam. These two layers work together to provide just the right balance for a quality sleeping surface.
Ready to sleep on your cloud? Shop the Puffy mattress and get the latest pricing at Puffy.com.
The Nolah mattress is a 10″ this mattress with 3 layers of foam. The top layer is going to be 2″ of Cooling Nolah Air Foam. This layer of foam is taking the best of memory foam and eliminating some of the less desirable attributes. This innovative foam is 4x better at relieving pressure it is also not sensitive to temperature and stays cooler than traditional memory foam.
The middle layer consists of 1″ of Avena Foam. This layer is similar to the feel of latex and will provide response and a bit of bounce, but is even more durable and stronger. Together these comfort layers make create an ideal amount of support and adaptability to relieve pressure from head to toe. The base layer is 7″ of dense base foam that makes for a more supportive base foam. These three layers work together to provide just the right balance for a quality sleeping surface.
Interested in the balanced feel of the Nolah? Shop and get the latest pricing at Nolahmattress.com
Puffy vs Nolah: Motion Transfer:
Both of these mattresses are all foam mattresses and that alone will make for minimal motion transfer. Each of these mattresses are 10″ of all foam that makes for little vibrations from movement. The Puffy mattress does have 3″ of memory foam on top that will respond quicker to reduce movement and eliminate it before it travels to your partner. The Nolah mattress does have 2″ of Nolah Air Foam, similar to memory foam, on top that will respond quicker to reducing movement and eliminate it before it travels to your partner. When comparing these mattresses side by side both perform fairly equally for isolating motion.
Puffy vs Nolah: Sleeping Cool:
As you already know, these are both all foam mattresses. Anytime you have all foam mattresses retaining heat may be more likely than on a mattress that utilizes a coil system. However, the Puffy and Nolah pays close attention to this factor. They both incorporate materials from top to bottom that help reduce heat retention.
The Puffy mattress incorporates cooling technology in every material of this mattress. The top layer of memory foam layer is a patent pending cooling cloud foam that uses convection and conduction to dissipate heat and keep it away from the body. It’s also infused with gel that increases the airflow 8x more than standard foam mattresses. The base foam is dense and supportive to create a solid base that won’t allow you to sink into the mattress and keep you closer to the surface where less heat will build around the body. The cover is also breathable to aid in keeping cool. All of this allows for the mattress to maintain an ideal temperature while sleeping.
The Nolah has a top layer of cooling Nolah air foam. This is a proprietary foam that is specially made without viscoelastic. By eliminating this chemical you also eliminate the heat sensitivity associated with traditional memory foam. This helps the bed stay temperature neutral as well as won’t react to your body heat and conform around you either. The Nolah mattress also uses a layer of Avena foam that is more responsive. This will help you move easier and not get stuck. The base foam is dense and supportive to create a solid base that won’t allow you to sink into the mattress. All of this allows for the mattress to maintain an ideal temperature while sleeping.
Both the Puffy and Nolah mattresses do a good job of maintaining a cooler feel than many all foam mattresses on the market. The Nolah uses slightly more responsive materials for easier moving. However, the Puffy is a little firmer and won’t let you sink in quite as much. As far as sleeping cool goes, both will perform well too and it is really a toss up.
If sleeping cool is a concern to you make sure you check out our Best Mattresses for Hot Sleepers.
Puffy vs Nolah: Edge Support:
Edge support may or may not be something that is a big concern to you. However, if it is than paying attention to how well constructed and durable the materials are will play a roll. Edge support is important if you either sit on the edge form time to time or if it is important for you to use the full edge to edge sleeping surface of your mattress. Making sure that even the edges are solid and hold up will make a difference in how comfortable it is as well as how it performs for you.
The Puffy mattress performs fine for utilizing the edge while sleeping. The mattress has fully usable surface and can be slept on from edge to edge. It may lack the desired support if you are sitting on the edge for an extended period of time. The edge support of the Nolah is not much different from the Puffy. You are able to use every inch of the surface for sleeping. But when it comes to sitting, there is a lack of support. Especially for a longer period of time. Both will have a solid, sturdy edge that will feel consistent and usable while sleeping.
Puffy vs Nolah: Value:
The Puffy mattress is $950 for a queen, this price does include shipping and has 101 night sleep trial as well as a lifetime warranty. This mattress is comfortable and well made and has a universal feel that the majority of people should enjoy. Also, you get a lifetime warranty. This is good for as long as you have your Puffy mattress and will cover replacing it if necessary.
Interested in the Puffy mattress? Learn more & Shop at Puffy.com
The Nolah mattress is $949 for a queen, and they also are currently offering and additional $125 off (Get the Coupon HERE). This price also includes free shipping and has 120 night sleep trial as well as a 15 year warranty. The Nolah uses innovative and comfortable foams that create a medium feel most should enjoy. It also currently comes in at a great price point of $824, after the discount.
Also, a HUGE plus that Nolah includes with each purchase is their charitable donation to the Defenders of Wildlife. For each mattress sold you get to choose which animal your contribution goes towards. You even receive an adoption certificate too. How cool is that!?
Interested in the Nolah mattress? Learn more & Shop at Nolahmattress.com
Puffy vs Nolah Summary:
We can say from both an objective as well as subjective standpoint that both the Puffy mattress and Nolah mattress perform well for online bed in a box mattresses. They have many similarities with the biggest differences being the feel, materials and price.
The Puffy uses 3″ of only memory foam that will make a slightly more contouring feel. It also will be a firmer feeling mattress too. While the Nolah will be contouring with a bit more responsiveness. It also will be closer to more of a medium feel and accommodate all sleeping positions easily. After the discounts and coupons applied the Nolah will also come in at a lower price than the Puffy. Both are great mattresses at good price points, but if you are looking to save money and have a more ideal feeling mattress, Nolah is our pick.
That’s Not All!
For more comparisons reviews make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all of our comparison reviews. Including Puffy vs Purple, Puffy vs Capser, Puffy vs Leesa and Nolah vs Casper. Also check out our Mattress Comparison Tool too for a really quick side by side glance at up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.
Not sure where to start? No problem! Let us help you start your mattress search with Our Mattress Guide to take out any confusion.