Please note, Our Sleep Guide is proudly supported by our readers. The product links you’ll find on Our Sleep Guide are referrals and if you purchase an item we do make a small compensation. Please see our disclosure page for full details.
If you’re in the market for a new mattress, there are two great brands you could consider. Both Puffy and Casper have created upgraded versions of their classic styles to give you luxurious sleep. The Puffy Lux has an extra layer for enhanced comfort. The Casper Wave increased its materials to include five foams with a precision cut layer for optimized support and contouring. You can get one of these mattresses at a much lower price than the other. Does that mean it’s a lower quality? Find out when you read our mattress comparison review on the Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave.
Puffy Lux – Overview:
Looking for a more luxurious feel? Puffy Lux has you covered. This upgraded version of the original Puffy mattress includes a new layer to enhance the memory foam feel. You’ll get deeper comfort with more response. You still get all the amazing benefits this brand has to offer. Free shipping, a 101-night sleep trial, and a limited lifetime warranty are yours with purchase. Are you wondering how a great mattress stands up to an upgraded model of a competitor? Read on to see the features of the Puffy Lux and the Casper Wave in our comparison review.
Casper Wave – Overview:
This upgraded version to the original Casper mattress stands 11.5 inches high. The Casper Wave is made from five different layers of thick foams to create this lavish sleeping experience. The most innovative thing about this mattress is the High Resiliency Foam layer which is cut into a Polymer Network. It provides precision support and contour where it’s needed most. Could the upgrade of a trusted brand win over another comparable luxury mattress? Read on to find out how the Casper Wave compares to the Puffy Lux.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave – Delivery and Off-Gassing:
Just like with its forefather, you get free shipping when you order a Puffy Lux. This mattress is compressed and roll-packed into a box for convenient delivery right to your door. Once you place your order, you can expect to see your new mattress arrive within five days through Fed-Ex. You may need a second set of hands to set up this 90-pound box, so call in some backup.
Off-gassing shouldn’t be an unpleasant experience since the Puffy Lux is made in the USA. This brand uses the highest quality foams that are all Certi-PUR certified. This keeps you from having to breath in any toxic fumes during your setup process. Simply place, unroll, and unwrap. Your Puffy Lux will come to life before your eyes as it expands. This should only take a few moments but allow it a day or two to fully firm up.
Casper is one of the original bed-in-a-box brands. Your new Casper Wave will follow this method of delivery compressed in a box for easy shipping. Weighing over one hundred pounds, the Casper Wave would be difficult to setup on your own. Once reinforcements arrive, place, unroll, and unwrap your new mattress.
It will take a day or two to fully firm up, but the Casper Wave will fully expand in moments. This brand is made in the USA with all Certi-PUR_US foams and low VOC’s. Any fragrances you notice shouldn’t be overpowering. However, if you are sensitive to smells, avoid the area for a day or so.
Puffy Lux – Comfort:
On a firmness scale where 1 is the softest and 10 is the firmest, the Puffy Lux is a 5.5-7. The true feeling will depend mostly on your size. Larger people tend to experience a softer feel, and smaller people will get a firmer feel. Since this mattress falls in what is considered a universal feel, most sleeping positions will be comfortable. The softness of the Cooling Cloud Foam™ gives you contouring at the pressure points for ample pain relief. You will feel sinking at the hip and shoulder when sleeping on your side. As well as a sense of hug at the neck and spine while sleeping on you back. You will also have deep support from the Firm Core Support Foam through your lumbar in this position. If you like to sleep on your stomach, you will notice that you have enough support to prevent back bowing.
This upgraded version of the original Puffy mattress is meant to give you a more opulent feel. The new layer enhances the memory foam feel for a deeper comfort. It is the perfect balance between soft and firm for all sleeping positions.
Casper Wave – Comfort:
If you want an all-foam mattress with a deluxe feel, the Casper Wave is a good choice. The medium feel will be good for almost everyone and accommodates all sleeping positions. You get precision support and targeted contouring along with the luxurious softness. A Polymer Network was cut in the layer of High Resiliency Foam. This gives you a balance between firm and soft in the respected zones of your body. This new technology focuses on a natural geometry system to mirror the shapes and curves of human anatomy. This aids in the restoration process that occurs while you sleep.
Puffy Lux – Materials:
In this upgraded version of the popular mattress you’ll get an added layer of foam for even more comfort. The top layer of this all-foam bed is Puffy’s Cooling Cloud Foam™. It is 3-inches thick to provide you a soft cushion that will feel like you are sleeping on a cloud. The Puffy Lux features convection and conduction technology to reduce the warmth around your body. It is infused with gel and has eight times more airflow than a standard foam. The new component in this luxury option features a layer of Plush Cloud Comfort. Two inches of foam perfectly contours to every curve of your body for pain relief in all the right places. You can also change positions easily with this responsive material.
The bottom layer of the Puffy Lux is the Firm Core Support Foam. The 7-inch thick layer gives you foundational strength for support and durability. The Puffy Lux is wrapped in the patented Puffy Cloud Cover. It is soft and cool to the touch for added comfort. This breathable material is decorated with tiny clouds and a stylish gray fabric on the sides. It is wrapped to the perfect tension to prevent bunching and sagging.
Casper Wave – Materials:
The Casper Wave was designed with five layers to create an 11.5-inch thick mattress. The top layer is a 1-inch thick Flo Foam. This breathable material creates a luxurious comfort with contouring softness. The next layer is a Latex Foam that measure 1.5 inches thick. This responsive component is a cool sleeping foam for continued comfort all night long.
Next comes the 1.5-inch thick layer of Visco Elastic Memory Foam. It contours perfectly to your body with support at the pressure points for pain relief. A High Resiliency Foam with Polymer Network comes next to make up this 1.5-inch thick layer. This supportive segment provides you precision contouring where you need it the most. The final layer is comprised of the Dense Base Foam Layer. It sets up the whole Casper Wave for success by providing an even surface of foundation.
Shop the Casper Wave and get the latest pricing at Casper.com.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave – Motion Transfer:
You’ll get some of the best results in reduction of motion transfer from the Puffy Lux. This all-foam mattress quickly absorbs vibrations with the combination of memory foam and plush foam. There are no bouncy coils or latex to disturb you with this awesome mattress. Firm foams will support you with a cocooning feel that blocks out almost all motion. The ability to isolate movement is an important quality for those who share their bed with a partner or spouse. This is especially true for light sleepers who are more easily disturbed. The Puffy Lux provides the minimal motion transfer you’ve been craving.
With five layers of thick foams, motion transfer is almost nonexistent with the Casper Wave. It certainly outperforms the other mattresses in this popular brand. You still have some response with the layer of latex foam, but the other foams quickly dissipate any residual vibrations. With a solid base foam to start this bed off on the right foot, any movement felt should be minimal. This bed is great for couples. Casper Wave does well if you’re on different schedules or need to get up frequently throughout the night. You and your partner should sleep undisturbed with this mattress.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave – Sleeping Cool:
The Puffy Lux uses the same Cooling Cloud Foam™ as the original Puffy mattress. This material is infused with gel to draw heat away from the body. It works with convection and conduction technology to disperse the warmth evenly across the bed. It is eight times more breathable than other foams, offering increased air circulation. Without these specifics, the memory foam would readily retain heat.
Firm support comes form the base layer of 7-inch thick foam. It is four times more supportive that other foams, creating a durable mattress that won’t bottom out. You will never sink in too far, where warm air can become trapped around your body. The cover of the Puffy Lux has a silky, soft feel that starts out cool to the touch. This breathable material creates a refreshing feel when you first lie down.
The downfall of the Casper Wave is that it doesn’t perform up to par with sleeping cool. The brand has given this design many additional features to keep it temperature neutral. Your experience on this bed won’t be bad, but you should consider other options if you sleep warm.
The latex foam layer in the Casper Wave is naturally aerated to encourage air circulation. It is also responsive to keep you from feeling stuck in one spot where warmth can get trapped. Specialized channels were cut to provide targeted contouring. These channels inadvertently also help with airflow. A breathable cover tops off this mattress for soft comfort.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave – Edge Support:
Edge support isn’t something you immediately think of when shopping for a new mattress. However, it is an important factor that can show you the true durability and quality of your new bed. You’ll want to look for a brand that offers a consistent feel at the sides and ends for sleeping purposes. You also need to consider how often you will be sitting at the side of your bed. You likely do this when getting ready in the morning or before turning in at night.
The Puffy Lux gives you a comfortable sleep all the way up to the edge. You shouldn’t get the feeling that you’ll roll out, giving you full use of every square inch. This is great news for couples who like to stretch out while they sleep. You could even occasionally sit at the side of this bed for a short time without much discomfort.
The upgraded Casper Wave was an improved take on edge support. The thicker materials instantly give this mattress a more durable and supportive quality. You won’t feel like you are going to roll out when sleeping right up to the edge. It also offers an okay experience with sitting at the sides for a short while. You will notice some light sinking if you sit down, but this isn’t unpleasant. The Casper Wave gives you adequate usage from side to side and end to end.
Puffy Lux vs Casper – Value:
The Puffy Lux is the upgraded version of the original Puffy, so the higher price is expected. You can purchase this mattress in a queen size for $1,795 at full price. This mattress also comes with a slightly higher price tag. The Puffy Lux is priced at $1,795 for a queen size. However, that doesn’t include exclusive $275 coupon with code: OSG275 making it ONLY $1,520. SHOP NOW! Or learn more in our full, in depth Puffy Lux Mattress Review.
Included in your price is free shipping to save you some time and money. You also get a worry-free 101-night sleep trial to make sure the Puffy Lux is the best mattress for you. A limited lifetime warranty also comes standard with the Puffy brand. This alone shows you what great quality this durable mattress must provide, with lasting comfort like sleeping on a cloud.
An upgraded mattress means a higher price point. The Casper Wave can be ordered in a queen size for $1,995. You can bring down this cost to just $1,945 with our coupon code: SLEEPGUIDE50 to save you $50. Shipping is included at no extra fee. You also get a 100-night sleep trial to make up your mind. A 10-year warranty comes standard with this brand.
Interested in the Casper Wave? Learn more and shop at Casper.com.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave – Our Pick:
If you’re looking at price alone, the Puffy Lux beats the Casper Wave by a mile. Even though cheaper isn’t always better, this might be the case in this comparison. You can purchase the Puffy Lux for $350 less than the Casper Wave after coupons. The come with comparable shipping and sleep trials. The Puffy Lux did a better job at providing a cooler sleep, which is crucial in all-foam mattresses. It also did just slightly better in other areas of comparison as well. If you still want to stick with the Casper brand, go for this upgraded version. We, however, feel that the Puffy Lux is the better choice for most consumers. Especially when you include the $275 coupon too. Just use code: OSG275 when shopping at Puffy.com.
That’s Not All!
For more comparisons reviews beyond the Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave mattresses make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all our comparison reviews. Including some of our most popular including the Puffy vs Purple, Casper vs tuft & Needle, Brooklyn Aurora vs Brooklyn Signature and Puffy vs Puffy Lux.
Or to make your own comparison selections use our Mattress Comparison Tool for a quick side by side glance at up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.