Your old mattress simply isn’t cutting it anymore and so now it is time to go mattress shopping. You want a comfortable mattress but you don’t want to feel like you’re putting a down payment on a car. Is it possible to get a comfortable mattress at a reasonable price?!
The great news is that there are plenty of quality comfortable mattresses like the Tuft & Needle and Nectar mattress that you can buy online that are going to give you years and years of premium comfort. The trick is to knowing which mattress to buy. Which is where we come in.
We are going to directly compare the Tuft & Needle vs Nectar Mattress to see which bed we believe gives you the highest quality comfort for your money. They are both cost effective, all-foam mattresses that deliver to your door. Which do you think will win? Keep reading or watch our video review to find out.
Nectar Mattress Overview:
- 11″ Mattress | 3 Layers
- All-Foam Construction
- Luxury-Firm Feel
- Memory Foam Quilted Cover
- Cocooning Sleep Surface
- Great at Deadening Motion Transfer
- 365 Night Trial Period
- Forever Warranty
- Price: $499 – $999
- Nectar Mattress Review
If you love a traditional memory foam mattress feel, then the Nectar is going to be right up your alley. The overall feel of the mattress is relatively firm, although it has a plush memory foam quilted cover on top giving it a plush luxury topper.
We also find that as memory foam warms up from your body heat, it gets softer and creates a bit of that sinking in feeling that memory foam is known for. Which can be one of those “love it or hate it” features.
Two of the biggest strengths that the Nectar mattress has is it’s ability to dampen any motion transfer, and it’s cocooning sleeping surface. Which we will get into both of those features in more details further on.
Nectar offers a 365 day sleeping trial with their lifetime warranty, but is it too good to be true? Maybe it is… All mattress warranties account for wear and tear overtime. So be sure to take that into account when making your final decision. Quality build is always better than a flashy sounding trial period and warranty.
Check out the full review of the Nectar Mattress HERE!
Tuft & Needle Mattress Overview:
- 10″ Mattress | 2 Layers
- All-Foam Construction
- Medium-Firm Feel
- Tuft & Needle Adaptive Foam
- Graphite and Gel blend
- Great at Deadening Motion Transfer
- 100 Night Trial Period
- 10 Year Warranty
- Price: $350 – $750
- Original Tuft & Needle Mattress Review
Tuft & Needle has managed to make their mattresses from quality products all in America. From their cover fabrics, finishing touches, even their foams are poured and cut right here in the United States.
Somehow, they manage to do all of this without cutting corners on comfort, while still keeping the overall customer price low. This is why T&N has gotten so much attention in the mattress world.
The T&N mattress that we will be looking at in this Nectar vs Tuft & Needle mattress review is their original model and design. They have since made upgrades that have more support and cooling features, but they have always kept around their original design for those who prefer it’s comfort and love that price tag.
Tuft & Needle vs Nectar: Which Mattress is Better?
- Quality Materials – Tuft & Needle
- Sleeping Cool – Tuft & Needle
- Edge Support – Tie
- Motion Isolation – Nectar
- Conforming Comfort – Nectar
- Supportive Comfort – Tuft & Needle
- Coupons – Nectar
- Price – Tuft & Needle
- Shipping & Delivery – Tie
- Warranty & Trial Period – Nectar
- OVERALL – TUFT & NEEDLE!
The Tuft & Needle and Nectar mattresses at first glance seem to be rather similar beds. In fact you may even think that the extra third layer of foam in the Nectar mattress may have even made it more comfortable or luxurious than the T&N.
However, when we took the Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattress and compared them side by side, going through all of the different qualities we use to base our judgments on. We found that time and time again we preferred the overall feel and quality of the Tuft and Needle mattress over the Nectar. Which is such a win due to the fact that it is less expensive.
These beds do have different comfort features that you may prefer over the other. Always remember that comfort is subject to preference and you may in fact prefer the Nectar. Keep reading to get more details on why we picked the winner we did for each category.
Nectar vs Tuft & Needle – Delivery & Off-Gassing:
Here is the bottom line, the longer a mattress is compressed for, and the lower the quality of foams within the mattress, the more off gassing or “new mattress smell” there will be. There is no way to know if any mattress has been sitting compressed in a warehouse for sometime unless a company claims they make each mattress fresh to order. (Which some companies do now.)
The Nectar bed is compressed, package, and shipped over seas from China to the USA. Since there are several holding locations in the US, you should not have to wait more than a few days for your mattress. However, it’s journey was a long one, which is why noxious odors and fumes may be trapped inside.
While the Tuft & Needle mattress is made in the USA which cuts out one of the steps in the manufacturing and shipping process.
Both mattress brands use foams that are certified by CertiPUR-US. Which means you can trust in the safety of their products. Tuft and Needle is also has a GREENGUARD Gold certification as well as a Intertek’s Clean Air Certification, which specifically rated the Tuft & Needle products as safe to use indoors with the smells that come off of their products. No nasty chemicals being released here.
Looking for a mattress that uses more natural materials? Then you will love our post on the Best Natural Mattresses.
Does the Tuft & Needle or Nectar Mattress Have Better Materials?
Nectar Mattress Materials:
The Nectar Mattress is all about the memory foam. This mattress is made out of three main layers of foam with a quilted memory foam pillowy cover that adds a luxurious top to this memory foam bed. The firm base foam supports two layers of memory foam one that supplies support while the top memory foam layer is the comfort layer.
Totaling in an 11” thick mattress, the Nectar has an all foam construction and is topped with a Tencel cover that wicks away heat and bedbug resistant. The top layer of memory foam is infused with a cooling gel in order to keep the memory foam as temperature neutral as possible. Which is a good addition considering memory foam tends to retain heat. Read further down to read more about sleeping cool between these two beds.
Tuft and Needle – Materials:
If there is anything for us to learn from here it is that comfort does not need to be complicated. The Tuft & Needle mattress only has two layers of foam. That is it! The first layer is a 7” layer of supportive base foam. This gives the mattress the majority of it’s supportive feel.
Then there is the 3” graphite infused top layer of foam. They use the graphite infusion in order to help draw heat away from you as you sleep on it. They also infused this foam with a cooling gel all to keep it as temperature neutral as they can.
The mattress is then finished with a light and breathable, Polyester and Micro Polyamide blend cover. This cover is plush and soft while also having the ability to dry 6-8 times faster than cotton. This helps to keep the sleeper cool dry and comfortable throughout the night.
No need to break the bank! Buy your NEW Tuft and Needle mattress NOW at TuftandNeedle.com.
Which Mattress is More Comfortable? Tuft & Needle vs Nectar
How Comfortable is the Nectar Mattress?
Comfort. It is the whole reason we buy a mattress. When it comes to the comfort of the Nectar mattress you may find yourself a bit stuck. Literally. Traditional memory foam like the kind used in the Nectar mattress sometimes has a way of feeling like sinking sand. This is due to the lack of responsiveness in old school memory foams.
With new technologies they are not all this way, however we did find the nectar left us feeling cocooned into one position. While some sleeping enjoy this cocooning effect, typically a more responsive feeling mattress (like Tuft & Needle) is enjoyed more by the general populous.
The combination of materials gives the Nectar Mattress a luxury-firm feel to the bed. This firmness level is perfect for back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers may find that this bed is too firm for you.
How Comfortable is the Tuft and Needle Original Mattress?
When compared to the Nectar mattress, the Tuft & Needle has a bit more pressure relief and lumbar support. Although it still has a medium-firm comfort level that gives the original T&N the optimal amount of comfort for most beds. Making the Tuft & Needle slightly better for back and side sleepers than the Nectar mattress.
If you sleep on your side most often, then you may find that there are better mattresses out there for you. While the T&N mattress does have better pressure relief than the Nectar mattress it is still limited due to it only having one comfort layer before the base foam.
Back and Stomach sleepers are going to really enjoy this mattress. As it has a good amount of give where you need it while also providing support where you need in most.
This foam also adapts more quickly than the foam in the Nectar. You also sleep higher up on the mattress without sinking in too far which makes it easier to switch positions. Overall for the price you’re paying this is a very comfortable mattress that will suite the needs of many.
Looking for the MOST comfortable mattress? Find all of our favorites in our Best Mattresses page.
Tuft & Needle vs Nectar – Motion Transfer:
What a great feature to discuss between these two mattresses. This is because they are both all-foam mattresses that use a memory type foam comfort layer. Memory foam and other similar foams are fantastic at limiting the amount of motion or vibrations travel throughout their surface.
Neither of these beds feature a hybrid construction which would have inner springs as part of the bed. Eliminating these springs also does a great deal of good when it comes to limiting the amount of movement that can be felt throughout the mattress.
Truly both of these beds are winners when it comes to eliminating motion transfer. However, if we had to pick one we would choose the Nectar because the traditional style memory foam simply cannot be beat in this category.
Nectar vs Tuft and Needle – Sleeping Cool:
When it comes to sleeping cool, this is where all foam mattresses tend to struggle. With dense layers of foam and memory foam tending to hold onto heat, it can be a combination that creates a rather warm sleeping mattress.
However, if proper precautions are taken you can have a temperature neutral sleeping experience. Nectar has a cooling gel infusion in their top layer of comfort foam. While Tuft & Needle uses three main steps to keep their mattress cool.
The first is a graphite infusion, the graphite helps to pull heat away from the body in order to keep you feeling cool. Then they added a cooling gel infusion on top of that. The third tactic that helps to keep their sleepers stay cool is open cell technology. This is allows their foam to have maximum amount of airflow possible in order to give heat a place to escape. This combined is what gives the Tuft & Needle the win in this category. Although we still maintain that if sleeping extra cool is your main priority in a mattress, we would point you in a different direction overall.
Do you want an extra cool sleeping experience? Head over to our page Best Mattresses For Hot Sleepers to find the bed of your dreams.
Tuft and Needle vs Nectar – Edge Support:
This is really yet another area where all-foam mattresses do not perform overwhelmingly well. In fact, if you’re planning on sitting on the edge of your bed for extended periods of time like a chair, then you won’t really enjoy these beds. However, we found that when it came to sleeping surface both the Nectar and the Tuft & Needle mattress allowed us to sleep comfortably all the way up to the edge of the mattress comfortably.
Now if you weight much more than 200lbs then you may find that the sleeping support will be less for you. Although for lighter weight and average weight sleepers will find that they can comfortably use the entire sleeping surface. Which is why these two beds get a tie in the category of edge support. For the price, the edge support will be just fine and if it is of concern, than focus on a mattress that uses a coil system or a more structured perimeter.
Nectar vs Tuft and Needle – Value:
Both the Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattresses are incredible low-priced beds. If you are looking to score a great deal, you have come to the right place. Whether you are looking to score a California King mattress under $1,000 or you are wanting a nice yet inexpensive kids mattress or guest bed, the Tuft & Needle or Nectar are just the beds you’re looking for.
Often times the more expensive mattress we are comparing tends to be the bed why find more comfortable and consider to be the better deal. That is not the case today. The Tuft & Needle just so happens to be our overall winner when it comes to comfort AND it is less expensive! Win win! Although Nectar is a great contender and it definitely a low cost bed.
The following prices do not reflect current promotions or our coupons! Be sure to click the buttons to get the latest coupons and save even more.
Tuft & Needle – Price
Twin XL: $395
California King: $750
Nectar – Price
Twin XL: $569
California King: $999
Tuft and Needle vs Nectar- Trial Period & Warranty:
We want to note that warranties tend to feature a lot of fine print and they take into account natural wear and tear overtime. So whenever you see flashy warranties like the Nectar’s “Lifetime Warranty” make sure you look at the fine print to see what all it covers just so you know what to expect as you mattress ages.
That being said, Nectar gives you a full year for their trial period. That is right, 365 days of trying out your mattress before having to choose whether or not you love it. We find that even 100 days should be more than enough time to adjust to your new bed and determine whether or not you love it. Nectar’s Lifetime Warranty will also bring you some reassurance that they have faith in the longevity of their mattress.
While Tuft & Needle’s trial period and warranty do not sound as lengthy they are going to give you more than what you need in order to try out your mattress and cover any issues the bed may have.
The fact that Tuft & Needle makes their mattresses and many of their materials in the USA should give you loads of confidence in the overall quality of their beds. A 100-Night Trial Period, 10 Year Warranty, along with Free Returns if you need it is really a great package offer from Tuft & Needle.
Which Mattress is Better, Tuft & Needle or Nectar?
Both of these mattresses do rather well with sales online. They both serve a similar purpose of having a really appealing price tag and a thinner profile all-foam bed. While they are both popular choices, after trying both mattresses side by side we simply prefer the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress over the comfort of the Nectar mattress.
The overall quality in build and materials is better with the Tuft & Needle, likely due to the fact that so much of it is made in the USA. We also find it has a combination of more pressure relief while also giving the bed better support where you need it as well. While the Nectar tends to cocoon creating an unsporting hammock effect.
You also can’t beat the fact that not only do we prefer the feel of the Tuft & Needle, but it also comes in at a lower price point. Don’t forget to click the links below to get our latest coupons and promotions.
If you like the idea of the T&N mattress but you do have the extra bucks to spend and you’re wanting to get an even more supportive or cooler sleeping mattress skip the Nectar and take a look at the other Tuft & Needle mattresses that are available at our post Tuft & Needle Mattresses: Original vs Mint vs Hybrid to learn more about the other beds they make.
That’s Not All!
Some of our favorites mattresses can be found in our Best Mattresses page. And if you are on a budget find several very affordable and durable options on our Best Mattresses on a Budget< page. Nectar and Tuft & Needle may have their spot, but we found neither of these mattresses to stand out above alternative options.
For more comparisons reviews, make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This accesses all our comparison reviews, including Puffy vs Purple, Puffy vs Capser, Puffy vs Leesa, and Nolah vs Casper.
Also, check out our Mattress Comparison Tool for a quick side by side glance at up to four mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.
Not sure where to start? No problem! Let us help you start your mattress search with Our Mattress Guide to take out any confusion.
Also, have questions for us? Feel free to contact us!