Please note, Our Sleep Guide is proudly supported by our readers. The product links you’ll find on Our Sleep Guide are referrals and if you purchase an item we do make a small compensation. Please see our disclosure page for full details.

August 1, 2017

Mattress Comparisons

Below you will find our list of comprehensive comparison reviews. These reviews put two mattresses with similar attributes, in some way or another, side by side. This allows you to see which one may perform better for you. These unique mattress comparisons pair our objective analysis along with our personal opinion. Allowing us to provide an in depth as well as one of a kind comparison.

Mattress Comparisons Featuring Puffy:
Mattress Comparisons Featuring Purple:
Mattress Comparisons Featuring Casper:
Mattress Comparisons Featuring Nest Bedding:
Mattress Comparisons Featuring Brentwood Home:
Mattress Comparisons Featuring Saatva Brands:
Same Brand Mattress Comparisons:
Other Brand Mattress Comparisons

Below find a brief synopsis of each of our mattress comparisons reviews; in order of newest to oldest.

Casper Wave vs Loom and Leaf Mattress Review: 
  • If you are looking for a premium all foam mattress than this is the read for you. Our look into the Casper Wave vs the Loom and Leaf will give you great insight into what both of these brands offer for a great night of sleep and rest.
Casper Essential vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review:
  • If youre on a tight budget than this is a must read for you. These two cost conscience mattresses, Casper Essential and Tuft and Needle, showcase two popular brands with mattresses that are under the $600 mark. See which is a better investment for your sleep.
Casper vs Yaasa Mattress Review:
  • The well nown Casper is going up against a fairly new hybrid option in our Casper vs Yaasa review. Letting you see if the original all foam bed in a box is still as good as the newer more updated competition.
Puffy Lux vs Casper Wave Mattress Review:
  • Check out these two upgraded all foam mattresses to see how they stand apart form the originals. Giving you a great insight to which one may be a better value and a better upgrade.
Cedar vs Zenhaven Mattress Review:
  • The Cedar by Brentwood Home is an luxury latex hybrid mattress that we are comparing tot he very high end Zenhaven by Saatva. See which mattress may be better for you in this one of a kind review.
Purple vs Molecule Mattress Review:
  • The Purple and Molecule mattress are going head to head to see which all foam mattress is better with pressure relief and sleeping cool. Both of these beds really focus on these qualities so now its time to find out which one did it better.
Purple vs SleepOvation Mattress Review: 
  • The name of the game with these two mattresses is “UNIQUE”. Both of these beds feature qualities that make them unlike any of their competition. Taking innovative design and materials to create specialized sleeping surfaces to provide benefits and rest like never before.
Saatva vs Luft Hybrid Mattress Review: 
  • Hybrids that are durable and solid make for a great mattress that will last you years to come. This is the case for both the Saatva and Luft hybrid mattresses. Making the winner of this comparison YOU, because both beds are outstanding!
Brooklyn Bowery vs Love & Sleep Mattress Review:
  • If you are looking for a budget friendly bed our Best Mattresses on a Budget is a great place to start. However, if you have it narrowed down between the Brooklyn Bowery and Love and Sleep than this review is for you. These two similar mattresses can be seen side by side to help you make up your mind.
Saatva vs Brooklyn Aurora Mattress Review: 
  • This review features two of our top rated hybrid mattresses. Neither is a bad choice, but both have different pros that may appeal to some sleepers more than others Learn more about these great brands and mattresses in this one easy to read review.
Purple vs Puffy Lux Mattress Review: 
  • You have read our Purple vs Puffy mattress comparison and still not quite sure? Than this is another great review to see the newer, Puffy Lux nest to the well known Purple mattress. See how this thicker and softer version of the original Puffy stacks up against the Purple bed.
Saatva vs Alexander Hybrid Mattress Review: 
  • This comparison may be exactly what you need if you are torn between the Saatva mattress and Alexander Hybrid Mattress by Nest Bedding. This review features not one, but both of these coil and foam mattresses. Giving you a great idea of which one may be better for you.
Leesa vs Cocoon Mattress Review: 
  • What’s not to love about each of these beds. One that has a great balanced universal feel and the other form a well known mattress brand that gives you several options. Learn more about the Cocoon by Sealy as well as the Leesa in this comparison. And make sure to save with our exclusive coupons too.
Nectar vs Brooklyn Bowery Mattress Review: 
  • Two all foam mattresses are put to the test in our latest comparison review. Learn which option is goingto suit your needs best in the Nectar vs Brooklyn Bowery review.
Leesa vs Bear Mattress Review:
  • Looking for an affordable all foam mattress that also is great quality, than look no further than either the Leesa or Bear foam mattresses. Both feature great materials and USA construction that won’t break the bank. Learn more bout what each bed has to offer in our side by side comparison.
Tomorrow Sleep vs Brooklyn Bowery Mattress Review: 
  • These two affordable all foam mattresses may have similar price points but there are quite a few differences between these two beds. We’ll take you through the pros, cons and advantages each has to offer in our comparison review.
Purple vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review: 
  • These two popular brands are crossing paths in  our comparison review. Testing the unique feel of the Purple polymer bed to see how it compares to the budget friendly Tuft & Needle. See if the added price of the Purple is worth it or if the less expensive T&N sleeps just as well.
Bear vs Tomorrow Sleep Mattress Review: 
  • These two mattresses feature 10″ of foams and memory foam comfort layers to create well priced and durable beds. See which one may be a better fit for you in this unique comparison. We can’t say either is a bad pick tough!
Loom and Leaf vs Alexander Signature Mattress Review: 
  • Looking for thick, plush layers of quality memory foam? Than this review is for you. We feature two 12″ thick memory foam mattresses in our Loom and Leaf vs Alexander Signature comparison. You’ll get plenty of bed with these two.
Nectar vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review: 
  • If you are looking for a mattress that isn’t only popular but also within a strict budget you may be looking at the Nectar and Tuft and Needle mattresses. Let us help you discover what to expect form both of these beds in our comparison of the two.
Bear Hybrid vs Luft Hybrid Mattress Review: 
  • If you are in the market for a hybrid mattress you don’t want to miss this. Our Luft vs Bear hybrid review takes a look at both of these fabulous and thick well made hybrid beds. You can’t go wrong with either one, but learn more in this comparison.
Casper vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review:
  • Casper vs Tuft and Needle takes two very popular brands and puts them side by side to see how they compare. This review looks at several areas of importance when choosing a mattress and gives you insight on how each of these brands performed.
Purple vs Bear Mattress Review:
  • They might both be all foam mattresses but the feel of the Purple and Bear are quite unique and distinct. See how these two 10″ beds stack up next to each other in yet another one of our our informative comparison reviews.
Puffy vs Layla Mattress Review: 
  • The Puffy and Layla are both memory foam mattresses. But that may be all they have in common. Read our comparison review to see how these beds differentiate themselves not only from each other, but other all foam mattresses too.
Leesa vs Nectar Mattress Review:
  • This comparison takes two popular all foam beds, the Leesa and Nectar to see which is best. Learn all you need to about these two well known brands to see what bed is a better fit for you.
SleepOvation vs Molecule Mattress Review
  • These two mattresses feature innovative and unique designs that make them stand out from the normal bed in a box. We will take a look at the SleepOvation and Molecule mattresses side by side to see what sets them apart and how their benefits may appeal to you too.
Zenhaven vs Spindle Mattress Review
  • Contemplating getting a 100% natural latex mattress? Than this review is a great place to start. Learn about the two sided Talalay latex mattress, the Zenhaven, as well as the adjustable Dunlop latex mattress, the Spindle. Find out all the details on both of these beds in one easy to find place.
Purple vs tulo Mattress Review:
  • Contemplating between the unique polymer feel of the Purple mattress and 3 comfort options of the tulo? Well than this review is for you. We are comparing these two brands and going through the benefits each has to offer. Learn more in our side by side mattress review.
Cocoon vs tulo Mattress Review:
  • Learn all you need to know about these two memory foam mattress from well known labels. The Cocoon Classic and Cocoon Chill by Sealy and the tulo by Mattress Firm are going head to head. Which is better for you? Find out here!
Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Review:
  • Two huge brands that came out in 2017 that brought their take on memory foam mattresses are put to the ultimate test in our comparison review. Puffy and Nectar may have different pros, cons and fair share of complaints. See how they stack up against each other in this mattress review.
Puffy vs Bear Mattress Review:
  • In this classic memory foam 10″ comparison review we are looking at two top brands that offer similar mattresses to see which may be better. Learn about each in this side by side review and get the latest coupons too.
Saatva vs Big Fig Mattress Review:
  • If you need a substantial, durable mattress than this comparison is one you don’t want to miss. These two mattresses are great for larger sleepers or any sleeper who wants a hybrid that will hold up for many years to come. Learn about the pros and cons to the heavy duty Saatva and Big Fig mattresses.
Puffy vs tulo Mattress Review:
  • Both of these memory foam mattresses have their appeal as well as rapid popularity. The tulo offers multiple comfort options at a great price. While the Puffy has one universal feel that is balanced and supportive with some additional benefits too.Which is best, find out for yourself in this unique comparison.
Oceano vs DreamCloud Mattress Review:
  • These two hybrid mattresses both might be on your short list of new possible beds. However, you will definitely want to read this first before making up your mind on which one is better. We will give you the details and inside look at the Oceano by Brentwood Home and DreamCloud to help you make the best choice.
Bear Hybrid vs Bear All Foam Mattress Review:
  • This is another comparison with the same company that makes multiple mattresses that we are testing out next to each other. This time is Bear Mattress, a company that offers their 10″ Bear all foam bed as well as a thick 13.5″ thick Bear hybrid bed. Find out which one is for you. Get the latest pricing at Bearmattress.com.
Nolah Signature vs Puffy Lux Mattress Review:
  • These two brands have quickly established themselves in the mattress marketplace with their original beds. Now they have both come out with upgraded mattresses that we are putting side by side to see if these improvements make one better than the other.
Saatva vs Loom & Leaf Mattress Review:
  • They may be made by the same company but these mattresses will definitely appeal to different sleepers. Take a look at what makes the Innerspring Saatva different from the Memory Foam Loom & Leaf in our unique comparison review.
Cedar vs Avocado Mattress Review:
  • If you are looking for a natural, responsive or cooling mattress this review is for you. In our Cedar and Avocado comparison we are taking tow very similar latex hybrid mattresses and breaking down the pros, cons and differences you will find between them
Layla vs Amore Flippable Mattress Review:
  • 2 Sided against 2 Sided. Could you ask for a better comparison review? In this mattress dual we will be looking at the benefits, pros and cons, similarities and differences between these two flippable mattresses. See if the Layla or the Amore Flippable may be a better sleeping surface.
Nolah Original vs Nolah Signture Mattress Review:
  • Nolah vs Nolah, we love comparing the same brands mattresses. This really showcases which each has to offer and the better selection for you, the sleeper. Learn more and compare the original Nolah 10″ ultimate side sleepers mattress to the new two sided Nolah Signature 12″ upgrade. Shop & Save at Nolahmattress.com.
Helix vs Morphiis Mattress Review:
  • If you are looking for a one of a kind, just for you mattress than this is the spot to look. We are putting these two customized mattresses side by side to help you understand the differences of each. Making finding the right bed for you that much easier.
Oceano vs Puffy Lux Mattress Review:
  • Are you not sure if you want a memory foam mattress or hybrid? This review is perfect for not only helping you determine which style is better but also which of these popular brands may be a better investment as well. Learn more in this unique review and help figure out which is best for you.
Nolah vs Cocoon Chill Mattress Review: 
  • The 10″ all foam mattresses are abundant and narrowing down the right one may seem difficult. However, we try to make it as easy as possible. Get the best insight specifically comparing the Nolah and Cocoon Chill in this unique side by side review.
Alexander Hybrid vs Brooklyn Aurora Mattress Review:
  • If you are torn between these two thick and durable well known hybrid brands this review is for you. See these two coil and foam combo beds side by side to learn the pros, cons and all you need to know about each one. As well as how they stack up in various areas against each other.
Puffy vs Tomorrow Sleep Memory Foam Mattress Review:
  • Memory foam vs memory foam is always of interest, especially if you’re looking for a memory foam bed! See how these two stack up, which one is the better value as well as a better fit for you. If you are in the market for a 10″ all foam bed and are confused with all the options, this is a great starting point.
Allswell Luxe Classic vs Bear Hybrid Mattress Review:
  • These may be different types of mattresses but that doesn’t mean that they don’t make for a great comparison. Seeing these two brands side by side may help you decide which option is best for you.
Puffy Lux vs Loom and Leaf Mattress Review:
  • The ultimate memory foam mattress comparison is here! The Puffy Lux vs the Loom and Leaf will show you exactly what each of these all foam beds will provide for you. Learn more in this amazing mattress review.
Ojai vs Luft Mattress Review: 
  • The Brentwood Home Ojai and the Luft hybrid mattress share several qualities. They also have many differences as well making them ideal to compare. Take a closer look at the pros, cons and benefits each of these thick and durable hybrid beds have to offer.
Allswell Luxe Classic vs Firmer Review:
  • Allswell is a brand new line that is offering not one option but two new mattresses. You get to select between their softer Luxe Classic memory foam mattress and their Luxe Classic Firmer hybrid option. The similarities and differences between the two are ample. Find out all about this brand now!
Brentwood Home Ojai, Oceano & Cedar Review:
  • Brentwood Home offers three luxurious hybrid mattresses the Oceano, the Cedar and the Ojai. These beds share some of the same features but also have several differentiating factors too. Learn more about all of these amazing mattresses and what they can offer you. Or shop now at Brentwoodhome.com.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora vs Signature Review: 
  • This is another same brand comparison that features two of Brooklyn Bedding’s most popular mattresses. The Aurora as well as the Signature. Both feature a hybrid build but with different as well as similar features that this review will help narrow down. Than shop and save at Brooklynbedding.com.
Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid vs Memory Foam Review:
  • Some of the best comparisons feature two mattresses from same brand. If you already know which brand you want to buy from the tough question may be narrowing down the specifics of each product. This review features both of the Tomorrow Sleep hybrid and Tomorrow Sleep memory foam mattresses and goes through the similarities and differences of each.
Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress Review:
  • This ultimate showdown features the original Puffy mattress against the upgraded Puffy Lux. These two beds have many similarities, but a few differences that set them apart too. See if the upgraded Puffy Lux bed is for you, or if the Puffy bed is the way to go. Get the latest pricing at Puffy.com.
Puffy vs Nolah Mattress Review:
  • The Puffy vs Nolah comparison review takes two beds that have similar goals of being the ultimate in comfort and cooling. These mattresses also have a current price tag of $950 for their 10″ all foam mattresses. These features and similar focuses make for a GREAT comparison review. Learn more now!
Alexander Hybrid vs KAYA Mattress Review:
  • The Alexander Hybrid vs KAYA mattress comparison review will help you decide which quality hybrid bed is right for you. Get to know the ins and outs of each mattress and how they’ll perform for you. This unique review puts two fantastic brands side by side for the perfect guide to your next new bed.
Casper vs Tomorrow Sleep Mattress Review:
  • These two mattress companies show what an industry veteran can stack up against the leader of the bed in a box boom. Find out if either of these 10″ mattresses is right for you, see their similarities and differences in our one of a kind comparison review.
Purple vs Yaasa Mattress Review:
  • These two brands not only share a common price point, but also unique qualities that set them apart from many other brands. In our Purple vs Yaasa mattress review we will be looking at the similarities and differences that you can expect from each of these beds. Side by side you will be able to easily see what each offers in that $1000 ball park.
Puffy vs Silk & Snow Mattress Review:
  • Puffy and Silk & Snow are two memory foam mattresses that offer a slightly firmer and slightly firmer feel. With many similarities and differences find out which of these newer all foam 10″ bed in box mattreses will give you a better night sleep in our one of a kind comparison review.
Purple vs Cocoon Mattress Review:
  • The Purple and Cocoon are two bed in a boxes with recognizable names. With Sealy behind Cocoon and Purple making their own way comparing these two brands makes for an intriguing review. These all foam 10″ mattresses have very different feels but many similarities.
Leesa vs Purple Mattress Review:
  • The Leesa and Purple mattresses are right around the same price point, have well known established brands, but how do they do side by side? Find out in our comparison review of these two 10″ all foam mattresses.
Leesa vs Puffy Mattress Review:
  • The Leesa and Puffy may share many qualities, but also have several differentiating factors too. See them side by side and compare these two all foam brands to see what is a better fit for you.
Casper vs Cocoon Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Cocoon by Sealy mattress review compares these two well known mattress brands. We are putting the Casper and Cocoon side by side  to see which one of these popular brands has the better bed. The similarities and differences may help you choose which is best for you.
Purple vs Tomorrow Sleep Mattress Review:
  • The Purple vs Tomorrow Sleep mattress review gives great insight to these two mattresses and showcases their similarities and many differences. If you’re thinking of either of these mattresses this comparison will help you make up your mind. Make sure you take advantage of all our coupons to save lots of $$ too!
Amore Hybrid vs Alexander Hybrid Mattress Review:
  • The Amore vs Alexander Hybrid mattress review is less about choosing one of these amazing hybrids over the other. It is mostly to spotlight both of these high quality durable and well made beds that provide great comfort, plenty of heat dissipation and a solid sleeping space from edge to edge. Either of these beds is an amazing deal and will deliver a ideally comfortable mattress right to your door.
Cocoon Chill vs Puffy Mattress Review:
  • The Cocoon by Sealy vs Puffy mattress review compares these two very similar mattresses by putting them side be side to see the pros and cons of each. Both are 10″ memory foam mattresses right at the same price point. One offers two firmness options while the other has a universal feel and one may be a little better if you’re a warm sleeper too. Learn more in this unique mattress review.
Casper vs Helix Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Helix mattress review is looking at two beds that are in the same price range. If you have a budget between $950 to $1000 than take a look at what you can get between the all foam Casper mattress and the custom hybrid Helix mattress. Both beds are 10″ but use different materials to create two different styles and feels.
Casper vs Nolah Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Nolah mattress review puts these two 10″ all foam mattresses side by side to see which one may be better for you. They may seem similar to the naked eye, but taking a closer look may help you figure out that they are different. Not only the materials, but pricing too!
Luft vs Nest Bedding’s Alexander Hybrid Review:
  • The Luft vs Alexander Hybrid mattress review is less about choosing one of these amazing hybrids over the other. It is mostly to spotlight both of these super thick, durable and well made beds that provide great comfort, plenty of heat dissipation and a solid sleeping space from edge to edge. Either of these beds is an amazing deal and will deliver a high quality, ideally plush mattress right to your door.
Casper vs Purple Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Purple mattress review compares these two online mattress giants. Putting the Casper and Purple beds side by side gives you a chance to see which one of these popular brands has the better bed, or if either really even do?
Purple vs Puffy Mattress Review:
  • The Purple vs Puffy mattress review gives great insight to these two mattresses and showcases their similarities and differences. If you are looking at both of these mattresses hopefully this comparison will help you make up your mind.
Purple vs Loom & Leaf Mattress Review:           
  • The Purple vs Loom and Leaf mattress review gives you all the details you need to know if you are torn between these two mattresses. Putting these mattresses side by side and evaluating them next to each other should help you feel confident in your final decision.
Casper vs Puffy Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Puffy mattress review shows two mattresses with very similar features side by side to hone in on the real differences. If you are torn between the Casper and Puffy than comparing these beds in a detailed comparison should help you make up your mind.
Casper vs Loom & Leaf Mattress Review:
  • The Casper vs Loom and Leaf mattress review highlights the very few similarities and vast differences between these two very popular mattresses. These two all foam beds may seem like they have plenty in common, however, really breaking down these two mattresses side by side will give you the insight you’ll need.
Tuft & Needle vs Eve Mattress Review:
  • The Tuft & Needle vs Eve mattress review is comparing two beds that are both very budget friendly. However, what do you get with these great price tags? We are helping you break down the differences and similarities of these mattresses to help guide you to making a confident choice.
Purple vs Helix Mattress Review:
  • The Purple vs Helix mattress review is here to help compare two very unique mattresses at the same price point. This comparison goes through the pros and cons of each mattress as well as provides an objective analysis as well as personal insight.

Not finding the mattress comparison you were looking for? Not a problem! Use our Mattress Comparison Tool to select up to four mattresses at once to compare side to side. Get all the facts on your favorite mattresses in a quick, easy to read format as well as the links to coupon codes too!

Always remember Our Sleep Guide is here to help you find the perfect bed. If you have any questions in your search always feel free to contact us.ess