Please note, Our Sleep Guide is proudly supported by our readers. The product links you’ll find on Our Sleep Guide are referrals and if you purchase an item we do make a small compensation. Please see our disclosure page for full details.

August 13, 2018

Casper vs Puffy Mattress Comparison

The Puffy and Casper mattresses are two mattresses that make for an ultimate comparison. These two mattresses both have a current price tag of less than $1000. As well as are 10″ all foam mattresses that claim to be the best bed in a box. Both focus on one mattress that is “perfect” for all sleepers. Lucky for you we have had the opportunity to try both out. Allowing us to give you a more in-depth comparison in our Casper vs Puffy review.

What Makes Casper and Puffy Different?

Puffy Overview:
casper vs puffy mattress comparison

Puffy was introduced to the online mattress market in 2017. The thought was inspired by one of the founders staring out of a plane window wondering what it would be like to sleep on a cloud.

The inception of Puffy was born and the ideal mattress for comfort, cooling and adaptability was found. This all foam mattress is a simple construction only consisting of 2 foam layers. A pressure relieving memory foam over a thick base foam. Together creating a medium firm bed that appeals to almost every sleeper and size.

Also, feel free to jump to our full Puffy Mattress Review. Or shop now and make sure to save $250 on your new bed with mattress coupon code:BESTPUFFY

Casper Overview:
casper vs puffy mattress comparison

On the other hand the Casper is one of the most recognizable online bedding brands to date. With this incredible marketing paired with their no-nonsense approach, online mattress shopping became more mainstream.

Their original mattress was a combination of foams that has been slightly altered over the years. This mattress is also focused on finding one ideal feel that will accommodate the vast majority of sizes. It is right at the $1000 mark and it’s reputation seems to proceed it still.

Check out more and shop the original bed in a box at Casper.com.

We are putting these mattresses head to head in our Casper vs Puffy mattress comparison. Looking at the similarities and differences and giving our honest feedback. Read on to find out how we felt about each of these brands as well as see which one will be a better fit for you.

Casper vs Puffy – Off Gassing & Delivery:
casper vs puffy mattress comparison

Most online mattresses will have the same shipping and delivery process. The mattresses will be compressed and rolled up and then put into a deliverable box. Both of these brands also use this convenient method. Making it fast, easy and less expensive. Both of these brands are manufactured in the USA.

The biggest difference may be that Puffy is made to order. Therefore it spends less time rolled up and in a box. Minimizing the time it is roll packed will help the off gassing by allowing for less time trapped in plastic. Opposed to the Casper that was packaged in advance and has been sitting in a box for a longer time.

When we unpacked these two mattresses we did experience a bit of off gassing. The Puffy was minimal while the Casper had a bit more of a noticeable scent. However, both fully dissipated within several hours. Another thing to note with both of these mattresses is that they took several hours to fully expand as well. The foams took about  24-48 hours to fully expand and firm up. Keep this in mind that the feel of the mattress will alter over the first few days.

puffy ad

Casper vs Puffy – Comfort & Feel:

One of the biggest determining factors for a mattress is the comfort. Figuring out which one is best for you without trying it may be a bit tricky. However, there are several objective ways to approach comfort to figure out what style, feel and option is best for you. The Casper and Puffy mattress will have slightly different feels but will have similar firmness levels.

As far as available options and firmness levels both are offered with one universal feel. Both are going to be a medium firm feeling bed that should appeal to the widest array of sleepers. The Casper will fall right around a 6 to 6.5 while the Puffy comes in just a hair firmer around a 6.5 to 7. However, the truer denser memory foam feel of the Puffy makes it initially feel firmer but while sleeping slowly contours to the curves of your body. Making it more adaptable and modifying the feel just a bit to accommodate you and your needs specifically.

our mattress guide

The medium-firm comfort level typically offers the right amount of support along with enough cushion to be comfortable for all sleepers as well. It is going to work well for all sleeping positions. As well as the largest majority of shapes and sizes too. The firmness level between these two mattresses won’t have much difference, but the type of feel provided by the materials helps make these two stand apart even more.

Puffy Mattress Materials:

The Puffy mattress is a true memory foam mattress. It is made up of two layers of foams to make a total of 10″. The top layer uses a cooling cloud foam for the first three inches. Under this is a supportive and dense base foam that makes up the remaining seven inches.

The top layer of memory foam is going to be great for providing pressure relief and evenly distributing weight. It also provides enough response and adaptability to easily move on too. The base is where the core of the support comes from. This layer also uses Insta-Firm technology which allows for better response and more support in the base. The top and bottom layers work together to create a balanced and ideal sleeping surface.

Interested in trying the Puffy and it’s cloud-like feel? Head over to Puffy.com to learn more. 

Casper Mattress Materials:

casper vs puffy mattress comparisonThe Casper mattress takes four layers of varying foams to create a 10″ thick bed. Starting with a 1.5″ layer of a latex alternative foam for a responsive layer meant to mimic the feel of latex. Next is a 1.5″ of memory foam layer for pressure relief and contouring comfort. The last comfort layer is 1.5″ of transition foam.

All of this sits on 5″ of base foam that is dense and supportive. These layers work together to find a harmonious balance of contouring pressure relief that allows you to easily move.  As well as enough support to provide proper alignment while you sleep.

Looking to try out the Casper for yourself? Get the latest pricing and shop and Casper.com.

Casper vs Puffy – Motion Transfer:

The Casper and Puffy are all foam mattresses that are ideal for minimal motion transfer. Each of these 10″ mattresses uses several layers of deadening foams to lessen vibrations and partner disturbance. Puffy does use only memory foam and the top 4″ will respond quickly to eliminating excess movement.

The Casper, on the other hand, does use a top layer more like latex that is slightly springy and may give off more bounce. This won’t be anything overly noticeable but comparing the beds side by side you would notice a difference. If you are very sensitive to movements and need a bed with great motion isolation than the Puffy would do a better job than the Casper.

Casper vs Puffy – Sleeping Cool:

casper vs puffy mattress comparisonAs stated earlier both of these beds are all foam. Anytime you have an all foam mattresses without a coil system you will have a better chance of heat retention in the foams. Between these two beds, the Puffy does focus on making sure that it stays more temperature neutral.  It utilizes properties in every material to counteract too much heat. Casper also incorporates different materials into their bed to help reduce heat as well, however, there are a few layers that may add to retaining heat too.

The Puffy bed uses the latest cooling technology in their foams. The first layer of the mattress is a cooling cloud memory foam. It is infused with gel to increase airflow 8 times more than regular memory foam. This patented layer also uses convection and conduction to allow heat to dissipate away from the body. The foundation foam is thick as well as dense to make for a solid base. The more solid the base is the less likely you are to sink into the bed. Keeping you close to the surface and able to get more air flow around your body. The cover of the Puffy is breathable as well, this also helps keep the surface cooler. Overall having a more ideal and temperature neutral bed.

Learn more about the Puffy mattress on our in-depth Puffy Mattress Review or at Puffy.com

The Casper mattress draws heat away by utilizing certain materials as well. The top layer of the bed has an open cell foam that is more breathable as well as better at pulling heat away from the body. The top layer also acts as a barrier between the memory foam and the surface as well. The Casper has a woven stretch knit cover that creates more air flow through the top. The top layer and cover help reduce some of the heat retention but may not do enough if you are a very warm sleeper.

If sleeping cool is a concern to you make sure you check out our Best Mattresses for Hot Sleepers.

Casper vs Puffy – Edge Support:

casper vs puffy mattress comparisonIf you like to utilize your mattress in full or tend to sit on your edge from time to time than edge support quality will interest you. Having a mattress that is fully usable for sleeping is very important. Not being able to sleep right up to the edge because of lack of support or inconsistency can be frustrating. Many times edge support coincides with the quality of materials and construction of a mattress.

As far as the Casper and Puffy go the edge support while sleeping performed as expected. You are able to use the majority of the surface without feeling much difference in consistency from center to edge. However, both mattresses do lack a more solid edge for sitting, especially for a period of time. If you need to utilize the edge of your mattress more a bed with a coil system would be a better solution.

Casper vs Puffy – Value:

While the price of a mattress may seem appealing or unappealing what you really need to focus on is the value. We like to make sure that this is differentiated and understood since value and price are not the same. The price is a set number for an item and the value is what you are getting for that price. We like to correlate value not only with a good price point but a quality and the benefits each provides. If you are paying the same price but getting a sub-par product than the value is not that great. There are several brands that will fall around the same price, but you really have to understand what you are paying for if you want a good value.

casper vs puffy mattress comparison

The original price of the Puffy mattress comes in at $1150. Currently, a $200 discount is automatically applied making it $950. And now we can also offer you an additional $50 coupon with code: BESTPUFFY to make it ONLY $900. With this price, you also get free shipping and a 101-night sleep trial. And a lifetime warranty that is good for as long as you have your Puffy mattress. Making this mattress a GREAT deal!

For this affordable price, you get a well made and reliable very true feeling memory foam mattress. It is supportive, comfortable for the majority of sleepers and provides a slow responding yet pressure relieving feel. It is great for reducing motion and has a solid, durable universal medium firm feel that appeals to many. This true memory foam mattress is a great option, especially if this is what you are looking for.

casper vs puffy mattress comparison

The Casper mattress is $950 for a queen size and does include the shipping in the price.  And now you can save $50 on your new Casper with code: SLEEPGUIDE50. Bringing it down to $900 too. This mattress also includes a 100 night sleep trial period and a 10 year warranty. This mattress may be right up your ally, and if that is the case, great.

It is a 10″ thick mattress with memory foam and poly foam comfort layers. One thing to note about this bed is the marketing that goes into it. Realizing that the ample amount spent on their beefed up campaign is included in the cost of each mattress is important. If the Casper is just what you want, then head over to Casper.com.

If you are looking for a mattress on a budget make sure you check out our Best Mattresses On A Budget. 

Casper vs Puffy – Summary:

We can say from both an objective as well as a subjective standpoint that both the Puffy mattress and Casper mattress perform well for online bed in a box mattresses. They have many similarities with the biggest differences being the feel, cooling properties and materials. Because the Puffy does use 4″ of memory foam there will be a more contouring feel than the Casper. The Puffy also incorporates a few more cooling features that may be better if you are a warmer sleeper too. These mattresses really are going to come down to if you prefer a slightly more responsive feel or a more true memory foam feel.

Still unsure? Check out the FULL review of Puffy and the Casper.

puffy adAt the end of the day we enjoyed sleeping on the Puffy a bit more than the Casper mattress. It has a much more consistent and pressure relieving feel that really adapts to your body and sleeping positions. It also feels more ideally supportive and much cooler. Both mattresses are true to their unique qualities and are going to come in right at the same price. And don’t forget that extra coupon available for the Puffy mattress. Use code: BESTPUFFY to get an extra $50 off. 

Casper vs Puffy… It Doesn’t End There

For more comparison reviews make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all of our comparison reviews. Including Puffy vs Purple, Puffy vs Leesa and Puffy vs Cocoon. Also check out our Mattress Comparison Tool too for a really quick side by side glance at up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.

Not sure where to start? No problem! Let us help you start your mattress search with Our Mattress Guide to take out any confusion.

For the full review of each of these mattresses check them out here: Puffy Review & Casper Review. Always remember Our Sleep Guide is here to help you find the perfect bed. If you have any questions in your search always feel free to contact us.