Please note, Our Sleep Guide is proudly supported by our readers. The product links you’ll find on Our Sleep Guide are referrals and if you purchase an item we do make a small compensation. Please see our disclosure page for full details.
Casper took the mattress industry by storm in 2014, when the bed-in-a-box concept gained popularity. Since then, the company has introduced two new designs to reach a wider range of customers. The Casper Wave is a higher-end design, bulking up on materials to create a thicker profile with more sleep benefits. The Casper Essential is the lower-priced category, with a thinner design containing only three layers of foam. How will you know which one to pick? With our Casper mattresses comparison review you can see all the differences each bed offers.
Original Casper – Overview:
When you think of online mattress brands, Casper is probably one of the first that comes to mind. This company is one of the forefathers in the bed-in-a-box industry. Their company states they have “one perfect mattress for everyone.” This 10-inch thick mattress boast a universal feel. This makes a comfortable balance between soft pressure point relief and firm support.
Sleeping in almost any position should be possible with this firmness level. It uses all-foam materials, creating a consistent sleeping surface with softness of memory foam and responsiveness like latex. The price range for the original design falls in the middle of the options available from Casper. Is this moderate-priced option the best choice from this brand? Find out when you continue reading this comparison review.
Casper Wave – Overview:
The Casper Wave is the upgraded version of the original Casper mattress. It features five layers of foam that stack up to create the 11.5-inch thick mattress. The core of this design features more pressure relief and support exactly where you need it. This gives you the best in proper spinal alignment in a variety of sleeping positions.
In addition to the upgrade in comfort, you will notice increased isolation of motion transfer, cooling properties, and edge support. You still get the benefits of ordering from Casper, like free shipping, a 100-night trial period, and a 10-year warranty. Is this upgrade worth the price increase? Keep reading this comparison review to find out.
Casper Essential – Overview:
In response to a growing need for affordability, this bed-in-a-box company created the Casper Essential. You get just the basics with this style that features three layers of foam. Similar materials from the original Casper were chosen to give you the exact benefits you need without breaking the bank. The design also falls into the universal comfort level category.
At 8.5 inches thick, this budget-friendly choice gives you support and pressure relief. Is this mattress right for everyone? Will this lower-priced choice give you everything you need for long-term use? This Casper brand comparison guide has you covered with the information you should need to make the most informed decision.
Casper Mattresses – Delivery & Off-Gassing:
The original Casper mattress weighs around 75 pounds. The Casper Wave weighs around 100 pounds. The Casper Essential weights around 65 pounds. It’s a good idea have a friend help you set up your new mattress, especially the Casper Wave. Shipping is included with the purchase of any three of the Casper mattresses. Your order will be compressed and roll-packed into a box for convenient shipping.
Upon its arrival, simply remove it from the box, unroll it, and remove the plastic wrapping. Your new mattress will come to life as it expands. It should only take a few moments to fully expand. However, it could take a day or two to fully firm up.
You may notice some smells from off-gassing during this time. The Casper Wave uses only CertiPUR-US foams and low VOC’s. Therefore, this option is the best choice for those that are sensitive to smells. Avoid the area if you these odors bother you while your mattress breathes. Once this period is over, you can place your bedding and begin to enjoy your new bed.
Ready to experience an original bed-in-a-box? Learn more at Casper.com.
Casper – Comfort:
You will find comfort in every position while sleeping on the original Casper mattress design. It follows a universal feel to create a surface that fits the needs of most average people. On a firmness scale where 1 is softest and 10 is firmest, the Casper rates a 6 to a 6.5. Back sleepers have ample lumbar support with contouring at the neck and shoulders.
Side sleepers will get nice support but may feel this mattress is too firm. It does not allow for a generous give at the hip and shoulder for ultimate pressure relief. Stomach sleepers can rest easy knowing they have the firmness required to prevent the back from bowing. Persons of larger proportions might need a firmer design in mattress to get the ultimate support necessary for proper spinal alignment.
Casper Wave – Comfort:
Due to the wave-like design in this mattress, you will feel varying levels of firmness throughout. This gives you the extra support where you need it and pressure relief at key points. Overall, this mattress will have a feel that should please most sleepers. Luxurious softness is paired with precision support to create the ideal comfort levels needed for restful sleep.
Back sleepers will get extra support through the lumbar. Stomach sleepers shouldn’t feel any back bowing. Side sleepers will get pain relief through targeting the pressure points. The foams utilized in the Casper Wave’s design are denser, providing you with a firmer feel than the original Casper.
Casper Essential – Comfort:
The Casper Essential was also designed to provide a universal comfort feel. With less dense materials, it could feel much softer to those who are heavier. This is also true for stomach sleepers who may need a firmer feel for ideal comfort. We wouldn’t recommend this mattress for couples to sleep upon full-time.
Though the price makes this a great starter mattress, you will notice it might not hold up in quality. You can find a better longer-lasting option if you spend a bit more. However, this is a comfortable option for a lighter person or as a mattress for a guest room. For these uses, you should find ample comfort for restful sleep.
Casper – Materials:
The original Casper mattress contains four layers of foam that stack up to ten inches in height. A 1.5-inch layer makes up the topmost portion. It is breathable and provides a soft feel with a responsive bounce. The next section is a 1.5-inch 4-pound memory foam that relieves pressure through a comforting contour.
The third segment is a 1.5-inch thick 2.5-pound poly foam that evenly distributes weight, providing a deepened comfort. The base of the original Casper is a 5-inch thick 1.8-pound density poly foam. It creates a durable quality and solid feel that supports the body in key spots. These foams are covered with a polyester fabric that adds another .5 inches in height. It is breathable, soft to the touch, and stylishly designed with a gray and white color scheme.
Shop for the true original Casper mattress at Casper.com.
Casper Wave – Materials:
This upgraded design got its name from the wave-like shaping of the materials in the core of the mattress. The Casper Wave stands at 11.5 inches tall and consists of five layers. The top segment is a 1-inch thick breathable Flo Foam that is silky soft to provide a high-end touch. The next layer is a 1.5-inch thick latex foam that is cool sleeping and responsive to movement. This prevents you from feeling stuck in one spot.
Next comes a 1.5-inch thick visco elastic memory foam that supportively contours to every curve in your body. Under this, the 1.5-inch thick high resiliency foam with polymer network that increases the support in a wave-like shape throughout. The bottom portion is a 5.5-inch thick dense base foam that creates proper spinal alignment. It also provides a consistent surface for the rest of the materials.
Find your upgraded design of the Casper Wave at Casper.com.
Casper Essential – Materials:
The Casper Essential has just the necessities, including three layers of foam in its unique design. The top layer is a 2-inch thick breathable poly foam. It is soft to the touch a provides a responsive quality. The next component is a 1-inch thick memory foam transitional layer that gives you a supported contour. The final piece is a 5.5-inch thick dense base foam that gives you support and consistency. This mattress is covered with a durable upholstery-grade fabric to give you use for years to come.
Find budget-friendly comfort of the Casper Essential at Casper.com.
Casper Mattresses – Motion Transfer:
All the Casper mattresses are only made of foam. Making motion transfer minimal across the board of options. You will find that there is very little movement felt across the original Casper mattress. Due to its design using all foam materials, almost all motion transfer is isolated. The dense layers will quickly absorb any vibrations from getting in and out of bed or changing positions.
Because the Casper Wave uses all foam materials, you shouldn’t experience much partner disturbance. The dense thick, dense layers will give you an even better experience in comparison to the other styles from Casper. If you have different schedules or get up from bed frequently, this is the best choice for uninterrupted sleep.
This new take on the original Casper mattress will provide you with a please night of undisturbed rest. The three layers of foam wonderfully absorb vibrations from changing positions or waking in the night. The Casper Essential does a commendable job at isolation motion transfer. However, it does not do as well as the other two styles from this brand.
Casper Mattresses – Sleeping Cool:
Typically, all-foam mattresses are not a favorite for sleeping cool. Manufacturers must include cooling properties into the design for this to occur. Luckily, the Casper brand has given thought to this area of comparison. The firmer foams will keep you from sinking in too far where warm air is trapped around your cocooned body. Increased air circulation is provided by the inclusion of a breathable cover and an open-cell foam layer on top.
The Casper Wave has included even more features to help you sleep cooler. Still, all-foam mattresses will not be the best overall at keeping you cool. This design incorporates a naturally aerated foam in the second layer of the design. This material is also responsive to allow you to rapidly reposition when you feel too warm. The support layers are also cut to include channels where air can readily escape. The cover is also made from a breathable material.
The Casper Essential is probably the worst of the three at giving you a cooler night of sleep. It does not include any extra cooling properties. You will also sink further in this mattress, which leaves warm air trapped around you. The only saving grace this design gets is from having a top layer of breathable foam rather than memory foam.
If sleeping cool is a concern to you make sure you check out our Best Mattresses for Hot Sleepers.
Casper Mattresses – Edge Support:
Edge support is an important factor to consider. Among the Casper mattresses you may find that they varying components do affect the edge too. With the original Casper mattress, you get a fully-usable sleeping surface. You shouldn’t feel like you will roll out. However, there are no additions to this design to increase the durability of the perimeter. This means you will feel like you are sliding off when sitting at the sides. This is a typical quality of most all-foam mattresses that can be ordered online.
The Casper Wave has the best edge support of the three different styles. It has a high-end feel due to the enhanced materials used in its construction. Dense foams are used in several layers of this design, creating a firmer feel. You can comfortably sleep all the way up to the edge and even sit at the sides for short periods.
Because the Casper Essential is thinner, you are going to immediately have less support. You can feel the compression of this mattress when placing all your weight in one area. This is extremely noticed at the perimeter. When sleeping at the sides, you might feel a “rolling out” sensation. You will also notice a sliding feel when sitting at the edges.
Casper Mattresses – Value:
You can purchase an original Casper mattress in a queen size for $950. A queen-sized Casper Wave runs $1,995. The Casper Essential is the lowest cost, at $600 for a queen size. All three of these choices includes free shipping with your purchase. You’ll get 100 night to try out any of these mattresses during your worry-free sleep trial. You’ll also receive a 10-year warranty with any of the Casper beds too. You can save $50 on any of the Casper mattresses using our coupon code, SLEEPGUIDE50 at Casper.com.
Interested in one of the the three Casper Mattresses? Learn more and shop all of them at Casper.com.
Casper Mattresses – Our Pick!
There is no true distinct winner among the Casper mattresses . Of course, the Casper Wave will provide you the highest quality with the best in every category. However, it is the most expensive choice. If you’re on a tight budget, the Casper Essential might be a good option. However, you’re going to notice that it doesn’t hold up as well for long-term use. This is especially true for utilization by couples or heavier people. If you want the best in quality for a more affordable price, go with the original Casper design. You’ll get everything you need for adequate comfort within a moderate price range.
That’s Not All!
For more comparisons reviews beyond the Casper Mattresses make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all our comparison reviews. Including some of our most popular comparisons. Including the Puffy vs Purple, Casper Wave vs Puffy Lux, Nolah Original vs Nolah Signature and Puffy vs Puffy Lux.
Or to make your own comparison selections using our Mattress Comparison Tool. Create a quick side by side glance of up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.